Discovering that two different documents claim ownership of the same property can be stressful and confusing. Whether it’s due to old paperwork, vague legal descriptions, or a seller transferring the same land twice, conflicting deeds and double conveyances can bring a land sale to a halt.
The good news is: these issues can be resolved. With the right approach, you can clear your title, protect your property, or decide whether selling as-is makes more sense. This guide explains what conflicting deeds and double conveyances are, why they happen, and the most practical ways to fix them—or sell your property without taking on the legal work yourself.
Quick Steps to Resolve Conflicting Deeds
If you’ve discovered a title conflict, here’s a clear roadmap:
- Gather All Records – Collect every deed, title report, survey, and transfer history you can find.
- Run a Title Search – Identify every document on record related to the property.
- Check Deed Priority – State recording laws determine which deed legally “wins.”
- Get Professional Help – A surveyor can confirm boundaries; an attorney can clarify ownership.
- Use Legal Remedies If Needed – Quiet title actions and equitable remedies can legally clear disputes.
- Decide to Fix or Sell As-Is – Weigh time, cost, and property value before choosing your path.
What Are Conflicting Deeds and Double Conveyances?
A conflicting deed occurs when more than one deed claims ownership of the same property. This might happen because of recording mistakes, overlapping legal descriptions, or fraudulent activity.
A double conveyance is a specific situation where a seller transfers the same property to two different buyers. For example:
Scenario: In 1995, Seller signs a deed to Buyer A but never records it. Two years later, Seller signs a second deed to Buyer B, who records immediately. Both deeds exist—but only one is legally valid.
The outcome depends on state recording laws (race, notice, or race-notice statutes), which determine whose deed has priority. Understanding this is key to resolving ownership.
Have a different type of title problem? Check out our complete guide to selling land with title issues.
Why Deed Conflicts Happen
Property ownership records aren’t perfect. Common causes include:
- Vague or outdated legal descriptions – e.g., “to the old oak tree,” which no longer exists.
- Unrecorded deeds – If someone never filed their deed, later buyers may take priority.
- Clerical or recording errors – Mistakes by county offices can create overlapping claims.
- Fraud or forgery – Fake signatures or unauthorized sales can cloud title.
- Accidental double sales – Especially when ownership passes through multiple heirs or unclear estates.
These problems often go unnoticed for decades, until a sale or development project brings them to light.
Common Types of Deed Conflicts
Not every title issue looks the same. Here are some of the most frequent scenarios:
1. Will vs. Deed Conflicts
If a will promises property to one person but a deed names another, the deed usually takes precedence for transfers made during the grantor’s lifetime. Wills become relevant after death, especially when no “transfer on death” or joint ownership exists.
2. Title Disputes
Beyond conflicting deeds, title disputes involve liens, easements, missing heirs, or improperly recorded documents. Any of these can create uncertainty about true ownership.
3. Boundary Disputes
Old surveys, vague descriptions, or misplaced fences can trigger conflicts between neighboring properties. A licensed surveyor can often resolve these by clarifying exact lines.
4. Adverse Possession
Someone using part of your land openly and continuously for many years may gain legal ownership through adverse possession—challenging your recorded deed. These cases often arise during quiet title actions.
Establishing Deed Priority: Who “Wins” in a Double Conveyance?
When two deeds claim the same property, priority determines ownership. States follow one of three recording systems:
- Race Statute: Whoever records first wins—even if they knew about a prior unrecorded deed.
- Notice Statute: A later buyer wins if they had no knowledge of a prior unrecorded deed.
- Race-Notice Statute (Most Common): A later buyer must record first and have purchased in good faith without notice of the earlier deed.
Understanding your state’s recording act is essential for resolving double conveyance disputes. A real estate attorney or title company can confirm which system applies to you.
Historical & Forensic Evidence: Solving Tough Cases
When the recording laws alone don’t resolve the conflict, historical and forensic evidence can fill the gaps:
- Original Land Grants reveal initial property boundaries.
- Metes and Bounds Descriptions clarify vague surveys using natural landmarks.
- Aerial Photography shows decades of property use and encroachments.
- Expert Witnesses like forensic document examiners or historical surveyors can authenticate signatures and reconstruct original boundaries.
This evidence is especially useful for older properties or complex disputes.
Legal Strategies to Clear Title
Several legal tools can resolve conflicting deeds and establish clear ownership:
Quiet Title Action
The most common remedy. This court process officially determines ownership and removes any competing claims. Once the judgment is issued, your title is legally “quieted.”
Challenging Fraudulent or Defective Deeds
If a deed involves fraud, forgery, undue influence, or lack of capacity, it can be challenged in court. Strong evidence is required, such as expert testimony or original documents.
Equitable Remedies
When strict legal remedies fall short, courts can use fairness-based solutions:
- Reformation: Corrects a mutual mistake in the deed.
- Rescission: Cancels a deed, often due to fraud or failure of consideration.
- Estoppel: Prevents a party from challenging a deed if they previously accepted it.
Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
Mediation or arbitration can resolve disputes more quickly and cheaply than litigation—especially useful when neighbors or family members are involved.
Other Important Considerations
Title Insurance
If you have title insurance, file a claim right away. The insurer will investigate and may defend your ownership in court or compensate you for losses. Be aware of exclusions—known defects usually aren’t covered.
Deadlines
Every legal claim has a statute of limitations. Waiting too long can permanently forfeit your rights. Courts may also apply the doctrine of laches, barring claims if delays unfairly harm the other party.
Professional Help & Costs
Resolving deed conflicts almost always involves attorneys and surveyors. Costs vary widely depending on complexity. An initial consultation will give you a clear picture before you commit to litigation or decide to sell as-is.
Fix It or Sell As-Is?
When you discover a conflicting deed or double conveyance, you have two main paths:
-
Invest time and resources to resolve the issue yourself, or
-
Sell the property as-is to a buyer who specializes in handling title problems.
Each option has advantages depending on your goals, timeline, and tolerance for legal processes.
Why You Might Resolve It Yourself
Fixing the issue yourself can make sense if:
- You want to maximize the sale price.
- You have the time and capacity to manage the process.
- You already have professionals in place.
- The problem is relatively simple.
The key tradeoff: you’ll invest time, money, and some patience now in exchange for a potentially higher payoff later.
Why You Might Sell As-Is
On the other hand, selling to a buyer who can handle the issue for you may be smarter if:
- You want to avoid legal and administrative hassles.
- The issue is complex or risky.
- You need to sell quickly.
- You prefer a guaranteed outcome.
The tradeoff: you’ll typically sell for less than market value, but you avoid the cost, time, and risk of fixing the problem yourself.
Final Thoughts
Conflicting deeds and double conveyances can seem overwhelming, but they’re manageable with the right strategy. Whether you choose to resolve the issue through legal action or sell your property as-is, taking action early is key.
Want to skip the legal headaches? Get a cash offer for your land here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a will more powerful than a deed?
No. A properly recorded deed usually takes precedence for transfers during the grantor’s lifetime. Wills control property after death.
What’s the remedy for a breach of deed?
Depending on the issue, remedies include monetary damages, specific performance (forcing the seller to honor the deal), or rescission (canceling the deed).
How do you terminate a deed?
Through rescission, reformation, a quiet title action, or recording a new corrective deed (such as a quitclaim or warranty deed).
Why would you remove a name from a deed?
Common reasons include divorce, gifting, death of a co-owner, correcting errors, or estate planning.
Please consult your financial advisor, accountant, real estate attorney, or tax specialist. This article is for informational purposes and is not tax or legal advice.
